Somehow every year Libby makes horrifying cries of pumpkin shortages. You have nightmares of visiting every supermarket in town, searching for pumpkin and imagine Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie, and Christmas without pumpkin roll. You worry about the cost of pumpkin with supply short and demand high, wondering who will be cut from the Christmas gift list to put pumpkin back on the menu. Okay so maybe it's not this dramatic, but you can save yourself a lot of headache and stress over pumpkin shortages (and get a better tasting, fresher, and local product) by making your own pumpkin puree.
Roasting pie pumpkins is easier than it sounds. Trust me.
Selecting Your Pumpkin
Many local farmers markets and have a wonderful selection of pie pumpkins. Many people use these cute little pumpkins for decoration, but inside lies a sweet, fresh, delicate flesh- perfect for satisfying those fall cravings.
Darker pumpkins that have some speckles on them are sweeter. If you are not planning to cook your pumpkins soon and intend to store them for a while, check them thoroughly for nicks and soft spots, as this is where rotting will begin. Don't forget to check the bottom and around the stem.
If you have a cool, dry place such as a fruit cellar or cool garage, you can store whole pie pumpkins. Stored in these conditions they can keep for a while (at room temperature a couple pumpkins lasted about only two weeks on my kitchen counter). Washing the pumpkins (or any fall squash) before storage can help extend the life of the squash extensively. My uncle swears by a light bleach solution, saying he has stored squash into the spring and early summer using it (although sources say pumpkins will store for 2-3 months). The solution should be 1 part bleach to 10 parts water. And the bonus of this- extra freezer space and pumpkin seeds in the middle of winter!
Roasting Your Pumpkin
Preheat the oven to 375 degrees. Cut your pumpkin in half, scoop out the seeds and pulp (save the seeds for some awesome cinnamon or spicy pumpkin seeds).
Pureeing the Pumpkin
Once the pumpkin has cooled enough to handle, peel the skin from the pumpkin and break into chunks. Drain the pumpkin in a colander, then process the pumpkin in a food processor until smooth. If the pumpkin is still watery after it sits, skim off the water.
My grandparents always canned their puree, but there are a lot of variables that go into packing an non-acidic food that can make it unsafe. However, the puree can be frozen in ziplock bags or containers.
Next....make some cake! Bake a pie! Mix up a pumpkin roll! Cook some pumpkin soup!
And if tasting this pumpkin and the fresher flavor of your fall favorites isn't enough, the two pumpkins I roasted ($1 each at Molnar Farms) made just over two pounds of puree, bringing the cost of pumpkin to about 6 cents per ounce as compared to Libby's at almost 14 cents per ounce!